Verification record — version 7
Word of Clout self-audit procedure
Self-audit record — Word of Clout’s own verification procedure, stated and signed. It asserts nothing about any practitioner; it is the audit of our own work.
This record states and signs Word of Clout's own sampling procedure: the frame, the draw, the retained ids, the error definition, the procedure faults, and the bound. It is an audit of our own verification work — it does not establish anything about any practitioner, source, plan, or provider. The observed tally comes first: of 50 drawn rows, 49 re-derived identically, 0 disagreed, and 1 was an excluded procedure fault — never counted as agreement. The 5.9% figure is the conditional binomial calculation on that run's tally — it holds conditional on that run's frame and draw, whose randomness is unestablished — never a score of any source, any plan, or any provider, and nothing broader than that one run.
The self-audit procedure — stated and signed
Other findings
The published receipt (sample-audit-n50-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256 4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b) records 50 distinct verification ids: 42 board and 8 NPI. Under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 v2 re-parse, 49 rows have expected == actual (agree); 1 row (row 13) carries a not-rederivable marker. Retained as published ledger extract at /verify/self-audit/2026-09-06T200705434Z/ledger/ (20/20 SHA256SUMS-verified) and /verify/self-audit/2026-09-07T043637637Z/ledger/ (50/50 SHA256SUMS-verified). Runner published at /verify/self-audit/observation-extract-runner-v2.mjs re-derives 49/50 agree + 1 NOT-REDERIVED (ver:board:mo-dental:2025005314:address_of_record:2026-09-04@old, PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 v2 rule-short-circuit).
Source: operator run receipt · observed Sep 22, 2026 04:27 UTC · rely until Dec 06, 2026 04:36 UTC (POLICY basis) · evidence
cannot establish — The frame is every verification row recorded in the Word Of Clout published-records store at cutoff 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z. The frame row count is not recorded in the run receipt; the frame hash at the cutoff was not captured.
Source: narrowed in the record chain: the published receipt cannot establish this property · observed — · evidence
What could establish it: a successor run that records the frame row count and frame hash at the cutoff
cannot establish — The draw used MongoDB's server-side $sample aggregate (sample_audit.js:91) against the frame. The sampler source that ran (sampler 51b81d94, sample_audit.js sha256 51fdb0dd3568cbe8faba3798a86428d341f66b052221fc9daf0075416333827d) is published at /verify/self-audit/sample_audit.js so the method can be inspected; no seed was recorded in the receipt, so the draw cannot be reproduced.
Source: narrowed in the record chain: the published receipt cannot establish this property · observed — · evidence
What could establish it: a successor run that records the seed, the RNG, and the draw algorithm in the receipt
Row 13 (ver:board:mo-dental:2025005314:address_of_record:2026-09-04@old) fault class NOT-REDERIVED / sub-cause rule-short-circuit - this is a RETROSPECTIVE classification assigned from the receipt marker and the sampler source, not an emission of the run itself.
Source: @4 narrowing - the classification is a later labeling, not a run emission · observed Sep 22, 2026 04:27 UTC · rely until Dec 06, 2026 04:36 UTC (POLICY basis) · evidence
0 disagreements in 49 re-derived rows; the exact one-sided 95% binomial upper bound on the frame error rate among re-derivable verification rows is 1 - 0.05^(1/49) = 5.93% approx 5.9%, conditional on the run design above (the 50 rows are the ones in the receipt; the frame, the draw, and the re-derivation for the fault row cannot be independently established for this run). The retained re-derivable artifact is the ledger extract at /verify/self-audit/2026-09-07T043637637Z/ledger/ with SHA256SUMS and the observation-extract-runner-v2.mjs published beside it.
Source: @4 narrowing · observed Sep 22, 2026 04:27 UTC · rely until Dec 06, 2026 04:36 UTC (POLICY basis) · evidence
2 published receipts: 951d0480bd92f162bf21986134e86f48ac3dbe47b37934b9a486042d50a0b776 published at /verify/self-audit/sample-audit-20260906T200704Z.out; 4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b published at /verify/self-audit/sample-audit-n50-20260907T043637Z.out.
Source: @4 narrowing · observed Sep 22, 2026 04:27 UTC · rely until Dec 06, 2026 04:36 UTC (POLICY basis) · evidence
cannot establish — The published run-inventory records 2 runs; run completeness rests on WoC host records — whether additional runs occurred is not independently verifiable from the published receipts alone.
Source: narrowed in the record chain: the published receipt cannot establish this property · observed — · evidence
What could establish it: every run appends its receipt hash to the signed host snapshot at run time
Technical section — signed and recorded material shown verbatim
Per-proposition provenance — verbatim from the record
receipt observable · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence route: /verify/sample-audit
observation: OBSERVED
authority: operator run receipt
read/comparison: recount of the published receipt; ledger extract published at /verify/self-audit/2026-09-07T043637637Z/ledger/ with SHA256SUMS; re-derivation runner at /verify/self-audit/observation-extract-runner-v2.mjs · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY
frame unverifiable · UNVERIFIABLE
verification: —
artifact cited: —
no evidence route is published for this proposition — see missing precondition
observation:
authority: narrowed in the record chain: the published receipt cannot establish this property (missing precondition stated on the proposition)
applicable rule: N/A
draw unverifiable · UNVERIFIABLE
verification: —
artifact cited: —
no evidence route is published for this proposition — see missing precondition
observation:
authority: narrowed in the record chain: the published receipt cannot establish this property (missing precondition stated on the proposition)
applicable rule: N/A
fault classification · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence route: /verify/sample-audit#fault-row-13
observation: OBSERVED
authority: @4 narrowing - the classification is a later labeling, not a run emission
read/comparison: retrospective classification under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 v2 · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY
bound conditional · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence route: /verify/sample-audit#bound-section
observation: OBSERVED
authority: @4 narrowing
read/comparison: exact binomial one-sided 95% upper bound; ledger extract and runner at /verify/self-audit/ published as retained artifact · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY
run inventory · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence route: /verify/sample-audit
observation: OBSERVED
authority: @4 narrowing
read/comparison: published receipt catalogue · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY
run completeness · UNVERIFIABLE
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence route: /verify/sample-audit
observation:
authority: narrowed in the record chain: the published receipt cannot establish this property (missing precondition stated on the proposition)
applicable rule: N/A
Record id
sample-audit-current@7
Read from the records ledger at request time
Verified at
Sep 22, 2026 04:27 UTC
when the supporting evidence was captured
Method
recount of the published receipt; ledger extract published at /verify/self-audit/2026-09-07T043637637Z/ledger/ with SHA256SUMS; re-derivation runner at /verify/self-audit/observation-extract-runner-v2.mjs
method read from the record’s own proposition method field — never a hardcoded summary
Historical verify
Sep 22, 2026 04:27 UTC
when this was last verified
Earliest recheck deadline
Dec 06, 2026 04:36 UTC
the earliest re-check deadline across this record’s propositions — no whole-record reliance state exists; each proposition’s reliance stands on its own card
Recheck basis
POLICY
the re-check basis of the earliest deadline, quoted from the record's own signed next_required_by_source field — the signed record is the only source of a recheck date
Public key
Ed25519 (SPKI) — shown in full below
embedded in this record
Signed scope — machine-replayable field enumeration; the sentences state their meaning
The signature covers exactly: id, schema, subject, created_at (the EVIDENCE CUTOFF — the newest evidence timestamp in the derived snapshot, NOT the issuance time), issued_at (the issuance time of THIS record, distinct from the evidence cutoff — a record can never acquire an earlier issuance time because its evidence is older), public_key, propositions (four-state verdicts only, POLICY next_required_by = min(90d interval, authority-stated expiry at 00:00 America/Chicago)), candidate_relations (evidence joins carrying no verdict), dependency_manifest, dependency_manifest_sha256, signed_scope_note, supersedes — every field except signature, signing, and derivation. The derivation block (the queries that produced this record) is display metadata, excluded from signing. dependency_manifest_sha256 is the SHA-256 hex of the canonical form of dependency_manifest (key-sorted, no whitespace) — the same recipe as this record's own canonical form (equal manifest values hash equally regardless of stored key order). The field names in this note are the signed field names — machine-replayable values, labeled as such; the sentences around them state their meaning.
Signature
sha256:c18f5dce31aafb87… Ed25519
re-computed at this render
-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----
MCowBQYDK2VwAyEAZAXc8TrIl05HTq4oDHbsc2Qf8SA6pydv3jbaUV4kSyA=
-----END PUBLIC KEY-----
How this record was derived — its provenance, repeat it yourself
This record was derived from the published self-audit run receipt at /verify/self-audit/sample-audit-n50-20260907T043637Z.out (sha256 4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b). The ids_artifact path is the PUBLIC URL. Supersedes sample-audit-current@6 per the chain law; the successor cures the predecessor's internal-vocabulary leaks by construction — every field re-stated clean. The verdicts are carried from sample-audit-current@6 unchanged. This successor applies the record-text self-explaining law: public record text states the world and the evidence, never internal vocabulary. This successor adds the signed extract inventory to the dependency manifest: every published ledger file's hash, size, and row count, and each run's expected re-derivation outcome counts, so the published verification runner refuses omissions and substitutions, not just wrong totals.
machine-replayable (structured query values for automated re-derivation; technical names, not prose — rendered to a reader only as a labeled machine block)
read the published receipt at /verify/self-audit/sample-audit-n50-20260907T043637Z.out (sha256 4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b)
re-parse under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1: outcome not_rederivable OR (expected not-rederivable-false AND actual false) → procedure fault, excluded from n
bound = 1 − 0.05^(1/49)
self-audit-run:2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z · sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92… · fetched Sep 07, 2026 04:36 UTC by the WoC operator, browser
Superseded history — a preview-key-signed sample of this record exists, bytes preserved, at the labeled preview path /verify/preview/sample-audit-preview-20260907.json — not production assurance, not linked from this record; see the current self-audit record
Verify this yourself — three independent checks
Material class: self_audit — this record audits Word of Clout's own procedure. It asserts nothing about any practitioner.
This is the record's canonical form. Ed25519 signature verification runs in your browser using a pure-JS implementation — no browser fallback, no SHA-256-only digest comparison passing as verification. Nothing is sent to us.
{"dependency_manifest":{"evaluation_cutoff":"2026-09-22T04:27:00.000Z","extract_inventory":{"inventory_version":"woc.extract-inventory.v1","note":"Complete file inventory of both published run ledger extracts: every file's name, sha256, and byte size (row counts for .jsonl files), each run's expected re-derivation outcome counts computed from the pinned bytes, the re-derivation reference implementation's own hash, and the omission-closed verification runner's hash. The signed record is the only trust root: a consumer verifies a downloaded runner against runner_v2.sha256 here before running it, and the runner refuses any missing file, extra file, changed byte, missing row, edited checksum list, modified re-derivation implementation, stripped inventory, or total mismatch — the count-only gate that accepted a deleted verification row is gone.","rederive_runner":{"bytes":8195,"note":"the re-derivation reference implementation published identically inside both run ledger directories; bound here at its own inventory entry so a modified copy cannot stand in for it (no self-attestation)","sha256":"d6961143fcc1c5fbd3dfc1d655aaa5981607196784cdd7a82b2f5e0c128fa533"},"runner_v2":{"bytes":31733,"note":"the omission-closed consumer runner; a downloaded copy is checked against this signed sha256 before it is run","path":"/verify/self-audit/observation-extract-runner-v2.mjs","sha256":"374d83ff139cc1bca654444110cf3c4827f4b7d3765539be8113e429f2371e93"},"runs":[{"expected_outcomes":{"agree":20,"disagree":0,"not_rederived":0},"files":[{"bytes":102,"name":"README","sha256":"64d89c25ca0fcb33bda0442f7f31c00746f70eee624056cc340dd114ab913183"},{"bytes":335,"name":"SHA256SUMS","sha256":"0b8c3b5c76d62a7fed818048c01f4a4a0a848d18130dc3fa5953b543e2c47fa5"},{"bytes":5806,"name":"observations.jsonl","rows":20,"sha256":"3bbdb00c515562f451ad8346ad49919242104ea6ea70a791f44f15e821b4ed92"},{"bytes":4630,"name":"propositions.jsonl","rows":20,"sha256":"48790e15c12d9ff8569646c893bb19c004b896ef097cb0e9ca5d1d951971bc78"},{"bytes":8195,"name":"rederive.mjs","sha256":"d6961143fcc1c5fbd3dfc1d655aaa5981607196784cdd7a82b2f5e0c128fa533"},{"bytes":8851,"name":"verifications.jsonl","rows":20,"sha256":"9cb70c59b5a179baa695195a2d717277c79a4af1ba5fa956eb67d96bd31acbf1"}],"ledger_path":"2026-09-06T200705434Z/ledger","public_url":"/verify/self-audit/2026-09-06T200705434Z/ledger/","run_id":"2026-09-06T200705434Z"},{"expected_outcomes":{"agree":49,"disagree":0,"not_rederived":1},"files":[{"bytes":102,"name":"README","sha256":"64d89c25ca0fcb33bda0442f7f31c00746f70eee624056cc340dd114ab913183"},{"bytes":335,"name":"SHA256SUMS","sha256":"aa09177a52e2e55e5125a6f0321916e5351c38484ef3bb04a8ee1b87a453f33c"},{"bytes":14368,"name":"observations.jsonl","rows":50,"sha256":"654d097772b84362ca9483374b13c68254525aa88f68da1e60520e120d57e881"},{"bytes":11533,"name":"propositions.jsonl","rows":50,"sha256":"772db988570f3e320b62e5e08182b4f6595646b267a3f4b3924c8645e6817e7c"},{"bytes":8195,"name":"rederive.mjs","sha256":"d6961143fcc1c5fbd3dfc1d655aaa5981607196784cdd7a82b2f5e0c128fa533"},{"bytes":23312,"name":"verifications.jsonl","rows":50,"sha256":"72fa9fee88c17fc274b818c94fbf3efddcc4496389cc12a4ca40de3c1a6e9b67"}],"ledger_path":"2026-09-07T043637637Z/ledger","public_url":"/verify/self-audit/2026-09-07T043637637Z/ledger/","run_id":"2026-09-07T043637637Z"}],"verify_root":"/verify/self-audit/"},"receipt":{"bytes":14731,"citation":"/verify/self-audit/sample-audit-n50-20260907T043637Z.out","name":"sample-audit-n50-20260907T043637Z.out","sha256":"4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b"},"ruleset_version":"woc.records.ruleset.self-audit.v1"},"dependency_manifest_sha256":"76e5a5660ade3e7650232a87e3e15cbca109703363b88c8105ded2bb015de138","id":"sample-audit-current@7","issued_at":"2026-09-28T05:00:29.351Z","material_class":"self_audit","propositions":[{"authority":"operator run receipt","decay_class":"unmeasured","evidence_class":"receipt_observable","id":"self-audit:receipt_observable","method":"recount of the published receipt; ledger extract published at /verify/self-audit/2026-09-07T043637637Z/ledger/ with SHA256SUMS; re-derivation runner at /verify/self-audit/observation-extract-runner-v2.mjs","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"The published receipt (sample-audit-n50-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256 4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b) records 50 distinct verification ids: 42 board and 8 NPI. Under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 v2 re-parse, 49 rows have expected == actual (agree); 1 row (row 13) carries a not-rederivable marker. Retained as published ledger extract at /verify/self-audit/2026-09-06T200705434Z/ledger/ (20/20 SHA256SUMS-verified) and /verify/self-audit/2026-09-07T043637637Z/ledger/ (50/50 SHA256SUMS-verified). Runner published at /verify/self-audit/observation-extract-runner-v2.mjs re-derives 49/50 agree + 1 NOT-REDERIVED (ver:board:mo-dental:2025005314:address_of_record:2026-09-04@old, PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 v2 rule-short-circuit).","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-22T04:27:00.000Z"},{"authority":"narrowed in the record chain: the published receipt cannot establish this property (missing precondition stated on the proposition)","evidence_class":"run_design","id":"self-audit:frame_unverifiable","method":"UNVERIFIABLE - missing precondition: frame count/hash at cutoff not recorded","missing_precondition":"frame count/hash at cutoff not recorded","next_admissible_step":"a successor run that records the frame row count and frame hash at the cutoff","proposition":"The frame is every verification row recorded in the Word Of Clout published-records store at cutoff 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z. The frame row count is not recorded in the run receipt; the frame hash at the cutoff was not captured.","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"N/A"},"state":"UNVERIFIABLE"},{"authority":"narrowed in the record chain: the published receipt cannot establish this property (missing precondition stated on the proposition)","evidence_class":"run_design","id":"self-audit:draw_unverifiable","method":"UNVERIFIABLE - missing precondition: no seed recorded; the draw cannot be reproduced","missing_precondition":"no seed recorded; the draw cannot be reproduced","next_admissible_step":"a successor run that records the seed, the RNG, and the draw algorithm in the receipt","proposition":"The draw used MongoDB's server-side $sample aggregate (sample_audit.js:91) against the frame. The sampler source that ran (sampler 51b81d94, sample_audit.js sha256 51fdb0dd3568cbe8faba3798a86428d341f66b052221fc9daf0075416333827d) is published at /verify/self-audit/sample_audit.js so the method can be inspected; no seed was recorded in the receipt, so the draw cannot be reproduced.","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"N/A"},"state":"UNVERIFIABLE"},{"authority":"@4 narrowing - the classification is a later labeling, not a run emission","decay_class":"unmeasured","evidence_class":"retrospective","id":"self-audit:fault_classification","method":"retrospective classification under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 v2","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"Row 13 (ver:board:mo-dental:2025005314:address_of_record:2026-09-04@old) fault class NOT-REDERIVED / sub-cause rule-short-circuit - this is a RETROSPECTIVE classification assigned from the receipt marker and the sampler source, not an emission of the run itself.","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-22T04:27:00.000Z"},{"authority":"@4 narrowing","decay_class":"unmeasured","evidence_class":"receipt_observable","id":"self-audit:bound_conditional","method":"exact binomial one-sided 95% upper bound; ledger extract and runner at /verify/self-audit/ published as retained artifact","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"0 disagreements in 49 re-derived rows; the exact one-sided 95% binomial upper bound on the frame error rate among re-derivable verification rows is 1 - 0.05^(1/49) = 5.93% approx 5.9%, conditional on the run design above (the 50 rows are the ones in the receipt; the frame, the draw, and the re-derivation for the fault row cannot be independently established for this run). The retained re-derivable artifact is the ledger extract at /verify/self-audit/2026-09-07T043637637Z/ledger/ with SHA256SUMS and the observation-extract-runner-v2.mjs published beside it.","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-22T04:27:00.000Z"},{"authority":"@4 narrowing","decay_class":"unmeasured","evidence_class":"receipt_observable","id":"self-audit:run_inventory","method":"published receipt catalogue","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"2 published receipts: 951d0480bd92f162bf21986134e86f48ac3dbe47b37934b9a486042d50a0b776 published at /verify/self-audit/sample-audit-20260906T200704Z.out; 4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b published at /verify/self-audit/sample-audit-n50-20260907T043637Z.out.","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-22T04:27:00.000Z"},{"authority":"narrowed in the record chain: the published receipt cannot establish this property (missing precondition stated on the proposition)","evidence_class":"run_design","id":"self-audit:run_completeness","method":"UNVERIFIABLE - run completeness rests on WoC host records","missing_precondition":"run completeness rests on WoC host records","next_admissible_step":"every run appends its receipt hash to the signed host snapshot at run time","proposition":"The published run-inventory records 2 runs; run completeness rests on WoC host records — whether additional runs occurred is not independently verifiable from the published receipts alone.","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"N/A"},"state":"UNVERIFIABLE"}],"public_key":"-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----\nMCowBQYDK2VwAyEAZAXc8TrIl05HTq4oDHbsc2Qf8SA6pydv3jbaUV4kSyA=\n-----END PUBLIC KEY-----","record_class":"self_audit","schema":"woc.record.v1","signed_scope_note":"The signature covers exactly: id, schema, subject, created_at (the EVIDENCE CUTOFF — the newest evidence timestamp in the derived snapshot, NOT the issuance time), issued_at (the issuance time of THIS record, distinct from the evidence cutoff — a record can never acquire an earlier issuance time because its evidence is older), public_key, propositions (four-state verdicts only, POLICY next_required_by = min(90d interval, authority-stated expiry at 00:00 America/Chicago)), candidate_relations (evidence joins carrying no verdict), dependency_manifest, dependency_manifest_sha256, signed_scope_note, supersedes — every field except signature, signing, and derivation. The derivation block (the queries that produced this record) is display metadata, excluded from signing. dependency_manifest_sha256 is the SHA-256 hex of the canonical form of dependency_manifest (key-sorted, no whitespace) — the same recipe as this record's own canonical form (equal manifest values hash equally regardless of stored key order). The field names in this note are the signed field names — machine-replayable values, labeled as such; the sentences around them state their meaning.","subject":"Word of Clout self-audit procedure — complete signed extract inventory for both published runs; verdicts carried unchanged from the predecessor record in the chain","supersedes":["sample-audit-current@6"]}
published digest c18f5dce31aafb87aaec9dd6b7ed57b8d1fae6b3ce01e4f069938fd879f19215
your browser —
If a published number cannot be re-derived from the ledger with the public key, it is a claim, and the record carrying it is void. That rule binds us before it binds anyone else.